Lorem Ipsm Dolor

Wish to fireplace your worker for FMLA fraud?: Employment & Labor Insider

As an example you might have an worker who’s in Week Six of “worker’s personal critical well being situation” depart below the Household and Medical Go away Act.

Her co-worker involves you and tells you that the worker on FMLA depart was seen engaged on Monday, after which headed out for a pleasant trip on Friday.

If this is not floor for rapid termination, what’s? It is falsification, which all the time leads to termination on first offense! The FMLA does not protect an worker from the results of her misconduct! See, e.g., 29 C.F.R. Part 825.216(d)!

The co-worker follows up and sends you two Fb posts from the worker. One, posted on Monday, exhibits her sitting behind the desk at a gun present. The opposite, posted on Saturday, exhibits her in a lounge chair on the shore of a fantastic turquoise physique of water, surrounded by white sand, palm timber, and flamingos. You bought her!

EXHIBIT A. That is the signal to the gun present the place she labored.

EXHBIT B. The seaside was similar to this, solely with palm timber and flamingos.

When the worker returns from her vacay, she calls you, and also you fireplace her. You are too indignant to even inform her why, nevertheless it does not matter as a result of she is aware of what she did.

Not lengthy after the termination, she sues your organization. You are not involved. Your organization’s legal professionals intend to “defend vigorously,” as they are saying.

However . . .

This is just a little background. Your ex-employee was a machine operator in your manufacturing plant. The job required her to face and stroll for nearly all of an eight-hour shift, aside from breaks. She needed to take FMLA depart as a result of she injured her knee. That made it unimaginable for her to face for lengthy intervals or to stroll, and also you had no different jobs accessible that she may do, with or with no cheap lodging.

Greater however

Hmm. Because the lawsuit progresses, extra info emerge. 

It seems that the worker missed her job and was going stir-crazy at dwelling, and the gun present was coming. She requested her physician, and the physician stated it was okay for her to work on the gun present so long as she’d be sitting many of the day and did not do any heavy lifting. In order that’s precisely what she did. She sat at a desk all day, chatting with the shoppers and being in command of the money field. She let the others do the strolling and lifting. It was enjoyable and actually helped her spirits. At the least, it did till you fired her per week later.

And that journey? She and her husband pre-purchased their Caribbean trip in St. Superior months earlier than she she injured her knee. The tickets and resort reservations had been non-refundable. Even so, she checked along with her physician, who instructed her that the journey was tremendous so long as she used a wheelchair within the airport and lounged round on the seaside all day after she bought there. In order that’s precisely what she did. 

In hindsight, she admits she ought to have defined this to you prematurely in case you heard about it from another person. And he or she was calling you to elucidate it the day you fired her, however you would not give her an opportunity.

Will you be capable to prevail within the worker’s lawsuit? Hmm.

Burnett v. Tallahatchie Faculty District

My state of affairs is loosely based mostly on an actual courtroom determination. The courtroom in the actual case determined that the worker’s claims towards her employer may go to a jury.

The true plaintiff was a toddler diet director for a Mississippi college district who went on a five-day journey to Jamaica whereas she was on FMLA depart. When the superintendent came upon about it, he had a cow and fired her, allegedly with out telling her why she was being fired. Like our fictional worker, the diet director had checked along with her physician prematurely, and her physician had accepted the journey.

Mini Quiz: Did the diet director sue for FMLA interference, or for FMLA retaliation?

Reply: It is a trick query. She sued for race discrimination.


The diet director, who was white, claimed that the superintendent, who was Black, discriminated towards white girls, and she or he discovered a number of different white present and former co-workers who backed her up. In her personal case, the mistreatment consisted of abruptly firing her with out clarification whereas she was on FMLA depart and following her physician’s orders. And, in case you forgot, which I am positive you did not, the decide has stated that her claims will go to a jury.

Do not shoot from the hip

After all, workers do typically do get caught faking staff’ comp accidents, taking fraudulent FMLA depart, or simply calling in sick once they’re not. These are all reliable grounds for termination. However do not shoot from the hip. If it seems that the worker’s exercise was constant along with her alleged medical situation and that the exercise had been approved by her well being care supplier, then the depart is sort of actually not fraudulent. Which signifies that in case you fireplace with out contemplating these prospects and conducting an sufficient investigation, you possibly can be liable — in a method or one other — for terminating an worker on a reliable FMLA depart.

Picture Credit: Gun present poster from flickr, Artistic Commons license, by Mike Licht. Seashore image from Adobe Inventory.

Leave a Comment

Refund Reason